Designing questions – or why 42 is the answer

In Douglas Adams’ novel *The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy*, when asked ‘the question about life, the universe and everything’, the answer – ‘42’ – generated by a computer after 7.5 million years of computation, comes across as more baffling than enlightening. But the crucial point is really the quality of the question, not the answer.

In this specific case, it is not entirely clear whether the problem really lies in the fact that the question was not phrased precisely, as the computer points out, or whether there is simply a lack of resources to place the answer in a meaningful context in relation to the original question, let alone to understand or even describe the question in all its complexity.

However, it seems worth focusing on how questions and their content can influence the answers – or even predetermine them. This is equally relevant to the design process, because every brief contains a question (or several), and in relation to this, every design (concept) provides corresponding answers (solutions). In summary, the following question arises: Do we need different questions to arrive at new answers – in other words, a new awareness of the questions involved in solving the associated problem?

Every design process – indeed, any desire to find a solution – involves a question, even if this is not always explicitly stated. In the design process, this starting point is referred to as a ‘briefing’, a term which, through the word ‘brief’, emphasises the conciseness of the set of instructions that contains or is intended to evoke questions. The shortest form of a briefing would be a single question.

The more concise the initial framework, the greater the freedom in finding solutions. This can be a good thing, but it can also be a bad thing. The broader the scope defined by a vague description, the greater the scope for solutions, but at the same time the greater the risk of losing one’s way. At the same time, a question that is too specific can also be a hindrance in the design process, because people tend to fall back on what they already know, which carries the risk that the ‘innovation factor’ will end up being rather low. But the question always arises as to how high the ‘innovation factor’ should be. If the 1,000th and second-to-last coffee machine isn’t supposed to be particularly different from the 1,001st before it, then surely it’s enough to aim low, isn’t it?

Questions determine their answers. There is a direct link between question and answer, simply by virtue of the overlap in their descriptions. An incomprehensible answer to a question may indicate that the answer is simply wrong, or it may point to a lack of explanatory frameworks and points of reference. Perhaps the ultimate answer to all questions is ‘42’. It’s just that we haven’t yet found the right code to decrypt it. Or perhaps we are unable to make use of the answer. We also need answers that help us move forward.

The dilemma begins with the question itself. How does one formulate a question intended to describe something one does not yet know, without resorting to generalised ‘clichés’? A product for the future. A sustainable product for the future. A sustainable, process-optimised and functional product. But what does that actually mean? What exactly is ‘the future’? Isn’t it merely an assumption, a combination of probabilities? Every question, therefore, follows an intuition in its own way and is thus a paraphrase on the path to finding a solution.

The first question is often not the only one, nor can it be considered in isolation. Rather, it demands to be placed within a context and gives rise to new questions. The creative industry has, to a certain extent, recognised this too, so that a ‘briefing’ is often followed by a ‘re-briefing’, which provides a content-based ‘update’ to the ‘briefing’, clarifies the questions that have arisen and allows for a comparison to take place between the questioner’s (the client’s) initial assumptions and the path of the solution-finding (design process), in order to rule out any future missteps. Essentially, however, the ‘re-briefing’ also serves, incidentally, to provide a safety net for the designer should it become apparent at the end of the design process that, although the path was taken jointly, it was the wrong one. Perhaps more time should have been devoted to ‘formulating’ the problem?

Ideally, the design process begins as soon as the initial question or task is formulated. Even at this early stage, a question is formulated that sets out a path towards finding a solution and thus influences the entire design process. Consequently, formulating the question(s) is not only the first but also a very important step on the path to finding a solution, as it plays a role in the solution that should not be underestimated. The designer’s focus should therefore always be on the question itself, and not merely on finding answers.