Analysis – or on parameters in the design process

In the design process, analysis is often prioritised over conceptualisation and drafting. This is what thousands of students learn year after year on their design courses. But what’s the story behind this? Identify the problem, solve the problem. Is it really that simple?

The use of the term ‘analysis’ implies that the subject under investigation can be better understood and described by breaking it down into its constituent parts. The complex is thus broken down into parts that are presumed to be less complex. These are evaluated and placed in relation to one another. The criteria for the investigation are determined by the subject and their context. At the end of the process, the individual results should be brought together and considered as a whole, leading to new descriptions and insights and thus driving the design process forward. So far, so good. But perhaps it isn’t quite that simple, and perhaps it creates more complexity than intended, even if unintentionally?

Three brief forays into the world of science:

Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle
The uncertainty principle, which originates in the world of quantum physics, states that it is impossible to determine both the position x and the momentum p of a particle with precision at the same time.
The more precisely one measures the position, the less precise the information about the momentum becomes. The uncertainty principle is not simply the result of measurement inaccuracy, but is based on a logical assumption that can be mathematically proven. The uncertainty principle is therefore of a more fundamental nature and is not rooted in the technical limitations of the measuring equipment. Roughly speaking, it could be summarised as follows: the more precisely one measures one thing, the less precise the measurement of the other becomes. Or: the more one focuses on one thing, the more blurred the other becomes.

Schrödinger’s Cat
This is a thought experiment which posits that a cat is situated in a closed chamber (black box) together with an unstable atomic nucleus. There is a certain probability that the atomic nucleus will decay within a specific time frame. The experimental setup involves a Geiger counter in the chamber, which can measure the radioactive substance in the event of decay and, at the very moment the measurement is confirmed, triggers a small hammer via a relay; this hammer shatters a vial containing hydrocyanic acid, which would cause the cat to die. This raises the question of exactly when the cat is dead and whether this can be determined with precision.

Black Box
The internal workings or structure are unknown or are disregarded. This reduces the complexity of the object or situation under analysis. What matters are input and output, task and result, stimulus and response. As the inner workings of the black box are unknown, the description is simplified (simplified assumption). This can open up new avenues for solutions. The unknowns (inside the black box) may possibly be replaced by a new design. The analysis is therefore deliberately simplified in order to focus on the outcome.

But let’s return to the analysis within the design process. Let’s suppose the designer is an archer.

Let’s now take a closer look at the image of the archer. What do we see before our eyes?

The archer selects an arrow from his quiver, nocks it onto his bow as he has learnt and is accustomed to doing, draws the bowstring to a certain tension of his choosing, aims at a target, releases the arrow and may well hit the bullseye.

All right, then?

However, there might still be a few questions:

  • Is the archer a beginner, an intermediate or an expert?
  • Who defines these classifications and criteria?
  • How do these factors and the archer’s skill level affect the shot?
  • What bow does the archer use, and why?
  • What arrows are in their quiver?
  • What criteria did they use to select the arrows?
  • Which target is chosen and why?
  • Is the distance known or chosen by the archer?
  • Is it windy, and which way is the wind blowing?
  • What mental and physical factors come into play at the moment the arrow is released?
  • And what if the arrow misses the target?
  • Is the arrow lost in the undergrowth, or is it worth looking for it?
  • But why does the archer search for the arrow – and thus for something he already knows?
  • Wouldn’t it be better to redefine the ‘target’?
  • Who says that the target was the goal and not the ‘undergrowth’?
  • Wasn’t the ‘undergrowth’ the answer to the question ‘target’?
  • Or was the path to the ‘target’ the wrong question to ask?

These are just a few examples of questions intended to illustrate how, during the analysis process, new parameters emerge which generate additional complexity and may cast doubt on the analysis process itself.

Analysis & Design
The whole is greater than the sum of its parts. This is correct to a certain extent, as complexity also increases with greater penetration. The analytical process therefore perhaps serves, first and foremost, to familiarise oneself with the subject matter, and only in subsequent stages to facilitate understanding and description; in doing so, the question of referentiality – that is, the subject-object-system relationship (the relationship between the signifier and the signified) – should always be clarified, insofar as this is at all possible. However, analysis always involves setting parameters. These automatically influence the outcome of the analysis and thus the entire design process. Perhaps it is time to let the design process begin before the analysis phase – that is, to shape the method of analysis so that, through the deliberate setting of parameters, we can arrive at different and therefore more innovative solutions?